« Do You Have a Lawyer Personality? | Main | Woman Power at Debevoise & Plimpton »

Harvard Law's Lonely Women

Vivia Chen

March 30, 2011


"Why do you keep saying you're shocked?" Lani Guinier (pictured center), a professor at Harvard Law School, prodded me during a recent phone conversation. I called Guinier (yes, she's the one who got pilloried by conservatives when Bill Clinton nominated her to be the assistant attorney general for civil right in 1993) to get her reaction about Harvard Law's latest milestone: granting tenure to its first Asian American woman--Jeannie Suk (pictured left).

Call me naive, but I was genuinely shocked that this big, prestigious bastion of liberalism didn't have a tenured woman of Asian descent until this year. (Harvard announced Suk's tenure last year, but few noticed, probably because everyone assumed that it already had tenured Asian women.) The much smaller Yale Law School, which has 60 full-time faculty members to Harvard's 100, has Amy Chua. Even more astounding, Harvard didn't have a tenured woman of color on its law faculty until 1998, when Guinier moved over from Penn. And Guinier held that fort all by herself until last year, when Annette Gordon Reed (pictured right) accepted a tenure position at Harvard.

Who cares about who gets tenure at some ivory tower? Well, I think it points to a systemic problem with diversity that plagues the whole profession. If minorities--particularly women of color--don't have status at one of the leading law schools in the nation, should anyone be surprised that they're not rising to the top when they enter practice? From the get-go, there's a dearth of role models for women of color.

Anyway, Harvard's rather pathetic record on granting tenure to minority women doesn't surprise NYU Law's Derrick Bell, who famously left his tenured perch at Harvard in protest over its poor record in promoting minority women. Bell e-mailed me:

Hiring Asians, men as well as women, has gone quite slowly even though Asians are an increasing percentage of students at the major law schools and generally perform very well. Hiring of any minority law teachers has proceeded quite slowly over the last ten or more years unless they have super qualifications of the traditional sort and are not outspoken or otherwise threatening to the still mainly white faculties.

Bell's views seem to comport with the findings of Katherine Barnes and Elizabeth Mertz, who studied the tenure process in law schools (see Social Science Research Network). They found that although 70 percent of professors polled "felt that the tenure process was fair," female and minority tenured faculty found the process "less fair," and that "female professors of color had the most negative perceptions."

And what do Guinier and Suk make of all this? Guinier would only say that she's "delighted" that Suk, a former student ("one of the most gifted students I've worked with"), is joining her tiny club. Suk, for her part, discounts that race or sex played any role in Harvard's snail-pace approach to promoting women of color. "I can't say that I felt discrimination," she says, adding somewhat cryptically, "There are complex choices, and subtle signals about what you should do."

Though Suk projects a nonchalance about her elevation, she's also aware that tenured women of color carry symbolic weight: "When I was a student here, Lani was the only woman of color--and it made a difference to me. And now my students tell me that it makes a difference to them."

Related post: First Gay Student to Lead Harvard Law Review.

Editor's Note: Jean Koh Peters was mentioned in the original post as one of Yale Law's tenured Asian American female professors. Yale Law informed us that Peters is a clinical professor and that clinical faculty is not included in the tenured count for ABA reporting purposes. We regret the error.

Do you have topics you'd like to discuss or tips to share? E-mail The Careerist's chief blogger, Vivia Chen, at [email protected].

Follow The Careerist on Twitter: twitter.com/lawcareerist


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

@ Legal Lohengrin. Even the most chauvinistic guys such as myself have no doubt that women are superior editors - if for no other reason than guys realize what a giant waste of time it is to dwell over grammatical details.

Its the substance, of course, where women tend to come up woefully lacking. And in that regard, sloppiness or even poor grammer does not an "illiterate" make, my dear.

I guess diversity is a slow process in Harvard.

I wonder what percentage of the population doesn't know that "Asian's" is not a proper plural for "Asian." Apparently, "DirkJohanson" is a member of this insular, illiterate minority.

I arrived at Harvard Law in 1991, in time to see students argue at Mass.highest court that women and minority students had standing to bring discrimination claims based on lack of mentors on the faculty.
Yes, it made a difference to have no female professors teaching in my section first semester.
Slowly, slowly, slowly.

@ Steve: Dirk ridicules the issue because most white guys - and it was white guys that made the changes - got on board for equal opportunity, only to later find out it was an endless scam on them, the major beneficiaries of which are wealthy white women.

BTW, I have a suggestion which should work out fair for the brilliant but overrepresented Asian guys in the School of Engineering and Applied Sciences: have them take a night course in law for a few weeks, and replace the females on the Harvard law school faculty with the science and engineering profs. I'm sure after a relatively brief amount of training, they'll make a lot more legal sense than the chicks.

Perhaps, if law schools are concerned about the number of tenured Asian-American faculty members, they should stop using affirmative action to discriminate against law school applicants.

Anyone who thinks what happens at Harvard is not reflective of law firm life for women is not a female lawfirm partner.

Dirk ridicules the issue because Dirk feels threatened (just being white is no longer good enough). Let's cry a river for him.

I actually don't think what happens in law school academia has any relevance to what happens in legal practice. It's a whole different ballgame. Different process, different kinds of people, different concerns.

However, I do think it is important to make it clear to Harvard et al. that people do notice these things.

I just checked on the stats for Harvard's School of Engineering and Applied Sciences. According to that school's website, 20% of its tenured faculty is Asian. http://www.seas.harvard.edu/faculty-research/people

Since Asian's comprise a far smaller percentage of the population, I find this highly disturbing. Clearly, Harvard needs to stop hiring Asian professors in its school of Engineering and Applied Sciences, and either transfer or discharge some of the tenured professors one way or another.

It has also come to my attention that nearly all Chinese restaurants are owned by Asians. This situation cannot be allowed to continue. All statistical discrepancies must be eliminated!

The comments to this entry are closed.

Subscribe to get The Careerist via e-mail

Enter your e-mail address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

About The Careerist

The Careerist takes an inside look at how lawyers shape their careers and manage their lives. The blog aims to dissect developments in the profession, provide useful information and advice, and give lawyers a platform to voice their views. The goal is to provide a fresh, provocative take on the state of lawyering.

About Vivia Chen

Vivia Chen

Vivia Chen, The Careerist's chief blogger, has been covering the business and culture of law firms for a decade. A former corporate lawyer, Chen is fascinated by those who thrive (as well as those who don't) in the legal profession. Her take: Success in the law (and life) doesn't always travel a linear path. If you have topics you'd like to discuss or information to share, contact her: [email protected]

To search across all ALM blogs, go to www.Lexis.com.